
I don’t watch “The Bachelor” on ABC and haven’t for some time, but I got a pretty juicy e-mail today from a guy who says he works in the media industry and knows bachelor Andy and his best friend “Gatsby.” I guess The Bachelor acts like a general doofus on the show, using over-the-top language and trying to come off as a Bill & Ted’s Excellent Adventure type. He’s not, according to this source, and is actually a very intelligent strategic guy who is well known by his friends for pulling stunts like this.
What’s more is that in last night’s episode he brought a “friend” he called Gatsby on to the show to help him decide between the final two women. The source says that Gatsby is an entrepreneur and triathelete named Mitch Thrower. He founded the La Jolla Holding group, which runs Triathelete magazine and active.com. He is also a lecturer at The University of San Diego in the MBA program.
When this guy watched The Bachelor for the first time last night, he was floored to see his old friends taking the decision to choose a mate so seriously, and knowing these two conniving womanizers, he says they were surely laughing behind the scenes.
Andy and “Gatsby” aka Mitch are probably going to come out and admit this prank to the world once the Bachelor has wrapped, the source speculates, and he thinks that they’ll publish a book and make some money off the experience:
Since I have not followed the course of the season I cannot verify how “Andy” has handled himself in the rest of the season, but from what I saw, he is almost mocking the show.
He used the words awesome and amazing and incredible almost every other word. The Andrew I knew was extremely well spoken and very strategic. He would not speak with this cadence.
So when the producers of ABC send his friend over to help him make “the most difficult decision of his life”, I saw the flash to his best friend who called himself “Gatsby”
I laughed hysterically because the only Gatsby is that of F. Scott Fitzgerald’s book, and this Gatsby on the Bachelor is none other than my old buddy Mr. Mitch Thrower of the La Jolla Holding group and active.com and a lecturer at University of San Diego for the MBA program.
I used to hang with Mitch in my triatholon day about 5 years ago back when we ran in the same LA/ Sand Diego athletes circle. Mitch and I did some business together, and I happened to know that the Great Gatsby is his favorite litearary character.
Mitch is a total smooth talker, and can appear very earnest, but he is the slickest charmer one would ever meet. What I knew of the bachelor who they call “andy” on the show is that he was a mini mitch in training. These are the kind of guys that get off on pulling the wool over people’s eyes in very subtle ways.
The fact that ABC let him on as Gatsby shows they did not do any fact checking,a nd they are completely and my guess, blissfully unaware that “Andy” is playing up this character on the show.

ITs the kind of frat boy like situation where they will all go back and laugh about the stunt they pulled off on America. Seeing Mitch portray himself on camera as Gatsby, I could see the repartee between him and Andy, and knowing them the way I do, it was clear that they were despearately trying not to keep straight faces.
So I guess the original story in my opinion would be that Gatsby is a fake, and they are making a mockery of ABC who did not know his name was Gatsby.
I have seen a couple reality show talent contracts, and if you are not the main star you just have to fill out a waiver etc.. and depending on the situation you can get a minimum appearance fee etc..
My guess is that Andrew and Mitch concocted for Gatsby to come on for free, that way they would not have to verify his employment information etc.. and my guess is that they did not pay for Mitch to come on (he is an extremely wealthy guy and he is often in Hawaii training for the Ironman. He also publishes a triathele’s magazine, is an author and runs the european division of active.com, along with being a venture capitalist and playboy) so they would not have thought to verify his name and information…
I am also venturing to guess that they had Mitch come on as Gatsby as an inside joke to their family and friends so that Andrew can look like he has the upper hand on the situation, and in case there was any embarassment they show that they outsmarted ABC. Mitch loves the Hollywood world, and he would think there was a way to use the visibility from teh show to promote a book for Andy etc… and my guess is that he would be his backer. That part is only a guess.
[Received via e-mail from source]
He goes on to say that it looked like these guys were just barely holding back the laughs, and that they’re “two of the most self-absorbed womanizers I have ever known.”

By Mitch Thrower coming on the bachelor as Andrew’s “ANdy’s” longtime best friend and them calling him Gatsby would put ABC in a bad position no matter which way you look at it. And”Gatsby” aka Mitch Thrower, was one of the major features in last night’s show. They did not show any backstory on Gatsby and “Andy”, but they had them hanging out in Hawaii talking in the hotel back and forth about the serious decision about which girl to chose… Andy’s amazing awesome feelings for these three “Incredible” women… it seemed like they were holding the laughs back to me because I have hung out with these two in social settings. Mitch can act with the best of them, but he is a businessman and Iron Man. Both of these guys in real life are two of the most self-absorbed womanizers I have ever known.
It’s probably true that “Gatsby” is this guy Mitch Thrower. I found his blog, and he’s got an entry about the Triathelete Bachelor Andy. He also has a profile up on Zaadz.com, and it says Mitch Thrower aka Gatsby.
At first I wasn’t sure I would run this story, because who watches this show anymore? A few days ago I had a link to spoilers to the show on Celebslam.com. They wrote “2001 called. It wants one of its popular TV shows back.”
If these guys pulled the wool over on producers eyes and are going to write a tell-all on it, at least it will drum up some interest in this tired old franchise. Let me know if you watch this show and have any insight into the situation.

Mitch Thrower aka “Gatsby”